Test report: ZA-D23 Tube damper
ßßß
The principle:
"Microphonics
describes the phenomenon where certain components in electronic
devices transform mechanical vibrations (ringing) into an
undesired electrical signal (noise). The term is derived by
analogy to older microphones where that behavior is inherent in
the design, while with modern electronics it is sometimes an
intentionally added effect.
When electronic
equipment was built using vacuum tubes, microphonics used to be a
very serious design problem. The charged elements in the vacuum tubes
would vibrate and the motion would change the distance between the
elements, producing charge flows in and out of the tube in a manner
identical to a capacitor microphone. A system sufficiently susceptible
to microphonics could experience feedback.
With the advent of
solid state electronics (transistors), this major source
of microphonics was eliminated but smaller sources still remain. The
ceramic dielectrics used in high-K capacitors
("Z5U" and "X7R") are piezoelectric and will
directly transform mechanical vibration into a voltage in exactly the
same fashion as a ceramic microphone. Wiring and cables can also exhibit
microphonics as charged conductors move around and various materials can
develop triboelectric ("static") charges that couple to the
electronic circuits.
The sound of
guitar amplifiers that incorporate the electronic chassis
into the same cabinet as the speaker are susceptible to microphonics.
Though a guitar amplifier's microphonics distortion is sometimes
appreciated as part of the "special sound" of a guitar amplifier, a
faulty vacuum tube or other component can cause out of control
feedback. Unwanted microphonics-related audible distortions can often be
alleviated by using commercially available vacuum tube dampers."
( Articles
from Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia )
We all know tubes
are microphonic in some way.
1) Transformer hum→ circuits/chassis→ tube
sockets→ tube pins→ tube grid.
2) Loudspeakers→ sound wave→ circuits/chassis→
tube sockets→ tube pins→ tube grid.
3) Loudspeakers→ sound wave→ tube
glass→ tube mica→ tube plates→ tube grid.
Tube grids are very
microphonic, because here is where the signal amplification takes place.
The idea with tube dampers is, when you make the tube glass heavier, and
also add some damping to it, you'll reduce the microphonic effects.
Reducing or eliminating these microphonics in theory increases the level
of detail, reduces the harshness and provides a better overall balanced
presentation to the music.
ZA-D23 Tube dampers; By
ZODIAC ACOUSTICS
For:
9-pin tubes and all tubes Ø3/4"- Ø7/8 (Ø19mØ22mm), including 12AX7,
12AT7, 12AU7, 6DJ8, 6922, 6BQ5/EL84, 6CA4/EZ81, and other glass types
having the 9-pin base.
Positioning: It
was quite easy, the ZA-D23 slips onto the vacuum tubes very easily . We
suggest to place the tube damper at about 1/4 the way down from the top.(Please
note, this is the part where the getter is, and supposed to be hot to
make the getters work better). You can experiment and try different
locations to see what works best for your HI-FI system.
Reference system:
Pre Amp : VTL TL 2.5 ( 2 x 12AU7 Amperex
Bugle Boy, 2 x 12AT7 RFT )
Power Amp : MSD - A400S
CD Player : Arcam CD73
D/A : California Audio Lab Sigma II ( 5751
Syvania 3 Mica )
Speakers : Canton LE 107
Speaker Cables : Transparent Music Chord
Interconnect Cables : MIT Digital Reference,
JPS Super Conductor, Nordost Hiemdall
Power Cords : JPS Power AC, Acoustic Zen
Tsunami MKII, Supra Lorad
Installation Step 1:
CAL sigma II with ZA-D23 & VTL TL2.5
without ZA-D23
First of listening,
without the ZA-D23 tube dampers in my reference system. I started with
my current reference CD, Opus 3 "Test CD 4.1", and played the track
No.16, "House Of The Rising Sun". This track has a very impression of
percussion transient. This piece makes it easy to place them in depth
and width of the stereo picture, so that they very nearly encircle the
vocalist. I replayed this track again and again until I remembered three
important subject fields for sound experience: depth of image, timbre,
dynamics. Next, with the ZA-D23 on the 5751 of CAL
Sigma II, at the tube about 1/4 of the way
down from the top. I replayed the track No.16 (House Of The Rising Sun).
The depth of image, timbre and dynamics sounded better than
without the ZA-D23. In different position, the ZA-D23 was placed at
about 1/3 of the way down from the top. Comparing the sound qualities,
the second trial had a bit less depth of image, also timbre and dynamics
but better than without them. The best position of the ZA-D23 for vacuum
tubes in CAL sigma II are at about 1/4 of the way down from the top.
Installation Step 2: CAL sigma II & VTL TL2.5
with ZA-D23
After installing the ZA-D23 onto the tube of
CAL
Sigma II, I were
experiment and try different locations of the ZA-D23 tube dampers onto
my VTL TL2.5 (2×12AU7, 2×12AT7). Once again, I played the reference CD,
Opus 3 "Test CD 4.1", the track No.16, "House Of The Rising Sun" for
comparing the sound qualities. The best position of the ZA-D23 tube
dampers for the 12AU7 Amperex Bugle Boy and 12AT7 RFT in VTL TL2.5 were
the same area in CAL Sigma II.
On Test:
On "House Of The
Rising Sun", Test CD 4.1, At the beginning of this session, I was
amazing that the sound of a Triangle on the left and a cymbal on the
right is very clear with power. The brilliant timbre of the attacks had
more airy, more extended and clean on top, and not even sharp or harsh.
The soundstage had deeper and wider. The overall presentation had
greater bass impact and clearer highs. The percussion had more transient
than without the ZA-D23 in place. The strings and double bass had low,
dense and well-define sound. The sax had more open and full-bodied
sound. Cyndee Peter's voice sounded natural and had more airy than
without the ZA-D23 in place. Her lovely voice conveys both powerful and
tenderness, wisdom and love.
On "Way Down Deep",
Jennifer Warnes' "The Hunter", I have heard a hundred times, until I
heard once again on my HI-FI system with the ZA-D23 tube dampers. At the
beginning of this piece, I was amazing that the sound of the surdo (bass
drum) more powerful like having air pressure, good punch and very deep.
Other percussion sounded larger and richer in tone; and even other
instruments you wouldn't normally expect, such as the seed-pod rattle,
lost a bit of harshness and more fullfill sounded. Musical details were
clearer, more delineated, more airy and ambience, nice extension on top
with a great sense of vibrancy. It was like everything in focus. Before
applying the ZA-D23 tube dampers, the lap steel guitar was located a bit
behind the middle and blurred, but after putting the dampers on, not
only did the lap steel guitar clarity increase, it moved more backward.
The talking drum moved further to the left, revealing a terrific
increase in the soundstage.
On "Hey You", Pink
Floyd "The Wall", After I placed the ZA-D23 to all tubes of my system,
it made a wonderful improvement in the quality of sound. It
started off with a solo acoustic guitar playing in the classical style.
Its sound had more open, more extended and clean on top,
and not sharp or harsh. The bass slightly sounded
deeper in shortly after. Next to joined with the
synthesizer that sounded more vibrancy, the vocals
had more full-bodied sound. Finally the
drums at about 1:57 of time scale,
solo perform of the drum set had more air pressure, good deep punch.
The sound of the
cymbals had more clear, and more extended. At about 2:01
of time scale, Gilmour's solo had
more clear, and very sweet as well. During this time, the rhythm guitar
sounded had a better detail. At about 3:23 of time
scale, the sound affect of the atmosphere
and emptiness sounded more realistic with a reduction of
harshness. With the ZA-D23 in place individual instruments was played
more life-like and was easier to place around you because everything had
more space or air around. They have made the soundstage deeper and
wider. This makes a lot more sense than changing cables.
Summery:
The
useful of ZA-D23 are
:
Reduces the harshness
:
Make larger and richer in tone
:
More extended and clean on top
:
More airy, ambience and vibrancy
:
More transient and deep bass
: Better image and soundstage
" That why I don't even think to live
without ZA-D23 "
Pricing : 500 Bht./pair
Available at www.musicfountain.net
|